Connect with us

Net Influencer

Net Influencer

Former Crocs social lead Sarah Whittle (right) in conversation with Emplifi's Stephen Adams

Brand

A Word Art Meme Outsold Crocs’ Traditional Ads, Says Former Social Lead Sarah Whittle

Sarah Whittle, who led social media at Crocs before founding the consultancy Unicorn Social, said the shoe brand’s best organic posts sold more as paid ads than its traditional advertising did, in a conversation with social media software company Emplifi posted to YouTube on November 10.

At Crocs, a team focused on purchases took the brand’s highest-performing organic posts and paid to show them to more people in a separate campaign. “Even something as simple as, like, a word art meme was converting faster and better than the, like, traditional ads they were pushing,” Whittle said.

The former Crocs social lead tied the result to repetition. Shoppers rarely buy the first time a product appears in a feed. “People aren’t buying Crocs on the first time they’re seeing them. They’re probably seeing it the second or third time,” Whittle said. A post that already earned attention without ad spend gives the paid team a tested starting point.

What Whittle Says Brands Should Do in 2026

According to Whittle, a brand that wants social media to drive sales in 2026 should start with small creators and spend its ad budget last. Emplifi’s Stephen Adams asked how to spend $100,000 on conversions, and Whittle passed on hiring one major influencer. “I think I would do a mix,” Whittle said. The money would go to micro influencers and user-generated content first, and paid social would follow behind whichever posts convert best.

That approach only works when a brand’s organic and paid teams look at the same results. The Crocs meme became an ad after the purchase team picked it up from the organic team, and Whittle told both sides to “share resources, share insights.”

Whittle also argued that much of the selling now happens away from a brand’s own feed. Creators and customer reviews carry more trust than a brand account, and micro influencers have a “higher level of trust” than celebrities. Success on other people’s accounts, in Whittle’s view, is “probably more impactful” than success on a brand’s own.

For brands without Crocs’ budget, the route in is creators who earn a commission. Crocs sells on TikTok Shop with its own livestreams, which most companies cannot afford. “Not every brand out there can put up its own bespoke livestream with talent and everything. So maybe affiliate and UGC is the way,” Whittle said, adding that sending free product to creators is the slower path.

Other Brands Pay to Extend Posts That Already Worked

e.l.f. Beauty follows the same practice. Kelly Shah-McDonnell, who leads connected commerce at the company, said in October that e.l.f. puts advertising behind creator videos that have already worked organically. ShopMy launched a product the same month that turns creators’ best-performing affiliate posts into paid ads on Meta and TikTok.

Crocs’ own TikTok Shop numbers show the weight of creators. The brand ranked seventh among TikTok Shops in October with $10.14 million in revenue, and $8.88 million of that came through affiliates.

The case for paying to extend proven posts grows as unpaid reach shrinks. “Engagement is going down, and the content being shown to followers is down,” Whittle said.

Subscribe to Our Newsletter


Check Out Our Podcast

Nii A. Ahene

Nii A. Ahene is the founder and managing director of Net Influencer, a website dedicated to offering insights into the influencer marketing industry. Together with its newsletter, Influencer Weekly, Net Influencer provides news, commentary, and analysis of the events shaping the creator and influencer marketing space. Through interviews with startups, influencers, brands, and platforms, Nii and his team explore how influencer marketing is being effectively used to benefit businesses and personal brands alike.

Click to comment

More in Brand

Latest Creator Economy Jobs

Tips, Comments, Suggestions? Email Us!

[email protected]
To Top