Agency
SWAI’s Olivia Dumnicka Argues Creator Content Pays Off Only When Each Video Shapes the Next Brief
A few creator videos a month used to count as a win for a brand, according to Olivia Dumnicka, founder of creator content agency SWAI. Today, in her view, brands need hundreds. At that volume, the videos only pay off if each one teaches the brand what to brief next.
“A lot of brands don’t learn from the content that they produce,” Olivia says. She founded SWAI in Berlin in October 2023 to build creator-powered content engines, running UGC and nano-influencer programs that produce social ads, mostly for Instagram and TikTok.
The model grew out of her earlier work running influencer campaigns at London tech startups around 2020, when she watched brands pay heavily for single posts from influencers who were already losing their audiences’ trust. “I’d much rather trust my friend’s recommendation, or a friend of a friend,” she says. “So why don’t brands pay normal people who have social media accounts just to recommend something?”
That trust argument underpins work for brands in Poland and across Europe, including Weleda, Unilever, GymBeam, and Foodsi. SWAI has produced more than 5,000 videos with a network of more than 1,000 creators in Europe and the U.S., according to the company. Using them well starts with knowing what a brand is paying for.
Follower Counts Matter Only When Buying Reach
Olivia splits what a brand buys from a creator into production and distribution, two purchases she says brands often confuse. A brand will ask for a UGC creator, then question why that creator has only 1,000 followers, even though the content is meant for the brand’s channels or ads. “Understanding if a content creator is going to perform well doesn’t necessarily have much to do with how many followers they have,” she says.
For distribution, the creator’s value lies in reaching the brand’s target audience, which brands often judge on the wrong signal, she argues. “Oftentimes they are looking more into the general aesthetic of a creator, but not necessarily into specifically their audience,” she says.
The split shapes cost too. In a written follow-up, Olivia said an ongoing program’s price depends on the number of creators and content pieces, usage rights, and whether paid distribution is included, and that creator and production costs should be kept separate from media spend. Once follower count drops out of the production decision, a brand can buy far more creators for the same money.

A Hundred Nano-Creators Test a Hundred Audiences
That is the case Olivia makes for splitting one influencer’s budget across many small accounts. “If we spread the same budget across 100 nano-influencers, then essentially we are targeting 100 micro communities who might have different problems,” she says. Those communities also trust their creators more, she adds, and the spread doubles as a test. “It gives us way more data on what works and what doesn’t work.”
Foodsi, a European competitor to Too Good To Go, has run on that model with SWAI for almost a year. Each month, the agency works with a few creators who have roughly 1,000 to 10,000 followers, according to Olivia. One, a small business owner, showed the app saving her time on a late lunch. Others focused on preventing food waste, or on cooking and healthy eating, giving one app several distinct use cases.
Spreading the budget produces variety. Learning from it depends on what the brand does with the numbers.
Retention Data Should Rewrite the Next Brief
A common failure, in Olivia’s account, is a brand handing the brief behind an underperforming video to another creator and hoping for a better result. What gets missed is the data. She points brands to the hook rate and the second at which viewers drop out, which can suggest a new hook or a tighter edit.
Audience data can change the casting too. “Maybe the video was created by a 20-year-old girl, but actually the audience consists of 40-year-olds,” Olivia says. “Maybe we should change the content creator to be an older content creator, and maybe then the same brief is going to perform better.”
In that scenario, the brief stays and the creator changes. Olivia credits professional UGC creators with the execution side of the loop, since they know how to use hooks and build transitions that hold viewers to the call to action. “Being a UGC creator professionally still means that you understand the craft of your role in this whole advertising system,” Olivia explains.
Her evidence that the format performs is client data comparing creator videos with in-house static ads and clients who return every month. Iteration also needs time, and Olivia says too many brands don’t give it any.
Programs Need Three Months Before Data Compounds
Black Friday is the case she cites. Clients arrive rushed, sometimes without a brief, asking for 10 videos, and the agency executes against the clock. “There is no real time for thinking about the impact of it long term,” Olivia notes. She would rather spend a few weeks on strategy, then run a longer program.
“Everything past three months is already when we have enough data to keep improving,” she says. SWAI then writes the next month’s briefs from winning content and drops the rest. “If every month you’re able to understand what really works, then more of your samples are going to start being the winning samples,” Olivia says. Volume and iteration reinforce each other. More videos mean more test samples, and each month of data raises the share built on proven briefs.
A trial can also end a program. SWAI planned around 100 pieces of content a month for a vertical wind tunnel, where visitors fly on a column of air. Phones would blow away inside, and footage shot through the glass caught reflections or one fixed angle. “You could solve that with a professional camera,” Olivia says. “But that’s not the point of content creation.” After a month, the agency and client agreed the format did not suit the business.

AI Takes the Work That Costs Humans Hours
That trial turned on the premise Olivia sets for creator content: it is quick and easy to make. Speed is also where she places AI. “I truly believe that AI is still not in the position to replicate a human,” she says, pointing to spontaneous footage with heavy camera movement and creators with strong personalities.
Animation sits on the other side of her line. A character like Duolingo’s owl once took a 3D artist weeks of work, she notes. “Nowadays, you can do it in half an hour.” SWAI is testing animated characters for one client, and once a character is settled, other AI tools build stories around it from simple directions, according to Olivia.
Brands that hesitate on AI have seen too much bad content and fear for their reputation, in her view. She points to a few companies running ads with the look of 1980s or 1990s cinema, which she says are cheaper and faster to make and can perform well. “If it’s going to be a piece of art, then I think the perception is different,” she says.
AI is one of three content sources Olivia says a brand should mix, alongside creators and influencers and what she calls CGC, i.e., raw customer-generated videos from people with no ties to content creation.
Customers and Commission Shape SWAI’s Future
That third source is where SWAI is placing its next bet. Olivia’s example comes from the UAE, where she recently relocated. A coffee shop there might offer a 10% discount on the next visit to customers who scan a QR code and share a photo of their coffee. “If you start involving everyday people who interact with your product, then you are able to create so much more content,” she says.
That reward costs a brand very little, and she expects more creator work to be paid on results. She cites TikTok Shop, where brands pay only once a sale is made, leaving agencies and creators to share in the revenue they help generate.
The bet extends her argument about volume. More people producing content gives a brand more samples to test, and paying on results ties spending to the samples that win. “This is where the industry is going,” Olivia says. “There will be no more burned budgets.”
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
Check Out Our Podcast
