Half of U.S. adults made at least one purchase on a creator’s recommendation during the 2025 holiday shopping season, and 85% of those buyers say they are likely to do it again this year, according to a new survey from Syracuse University’s Center for the Creator Economy.
The center’s second “Flash Report,” dated November 2026, surveyed 988 U.S. adults through Prolific on November 7 and 8. The sample is nationally representative by gender, age, ethnicity, and political affiliation. Respondents answered questions about last year’s holiday shopping, defined as September through December 2025, and about their plans for this season.
Across all respondents, 61% said they are somewhat or very likely to buy a creator-recommended gift this season. Among adults who did not buy on a creator’s recommendation last year, or were unsure whether they had, the share falls to 22%.
Creator Influence Peaked on the Biggest Shopping Days
Creator recommendations reached shoppers on the season’s highest-traffic days. Of all respondents, 37% bought on a creator’s recommendation on Black Friday, 26% did so on Cyber Monday, and 33% bought a creator-recommended item as a last-minute gift.
Women were more likely than men to have made a creator-recommended purchase last season, and more likely to plan one this season, the report found.
Three in Four Save Gift Ideas From Creators
Seventy-seven percent of U.S. adults save gift ideas from creators, and most do so with other people in mind. Sixty-five percent save creator posts as gift ideas for others, including 47% who save for both themselves and others. Another 10.6% save ideas only to buy for themselves later, while 22.6% do not save creator gift ideas at all.
Women and adults ages 18 to 44 were the most likely to save gift ideas from creators.
Among the 765 respondents who saved gift ideas, Instagram (60%), YouTube (59%), and TikTok (53%) were the leading platforms where those ideas are stored. Facebook followed at 43.5% and Pinterest at 20.3%. The order shifts when respondents pass ideas along. Among the 529 who had shared or planned to share saved products with family or friends as a wish list, Instagram ranked first at 59%, followed by TikTok at 54% and YouTube at 48%.
Shoppers See Deal Posts as Ads, and Many Still Use Them
Seventy percent of respondents agree that creators’ Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal promotions are “mostly just advertising,” with 35% agreeing strongly. At the same time, 53% agree that creators help them find deals that are “actually worth it.”
Most adults also say they can identify paid content. Fifty-six percent are “very” or “extremely” confident they could tell when a creator is being paid to promote a product, and 59% say the same about spotting a commission link. Confidence drops to 45% when a creator is promoting a product received for free from the brand.
Creators Trail Brands Narrowly on Trust
Friends and family remain the most trusted source of gift ideas, with 75% of adults trusting them “very much” or “completely.” Customer reviews followed at 48% on the same measure.
On a broader measure of moderate or higher trust, creators reached 53%, compared with 55% for brands, 47% for AI, and 25% for celebrities. Twenty-four percent of respondents said they do not trust AI at all for gift ideas, and 39% said the same of celebrities.
Creators also steer some shoppers away from purchases. Sixteen percent of respondents, or 158 people, said a creator talked them out of a gift last season. Among that group, 38% were pointed to a better or higher-quality alternative, 25% to a cheaper alternative, and 23% were talked out of the product altogether. Smaller shares cited a more sustainable alternative (8.2%), a suggestion to craft the gift instead (3.8%), or encouragement to give experiences over gifts (1.9%).
Beauty and Fashion Lead Creator-Influenced Categories
Beauty and personal care topped the list of creator-influenced gift categories at 68%, followed by clothing, shoes, and accessories at 66%, electronics and gadgets at 64%, and home and kitchen at 61%. Toys and games came in at 56%, food and drink and books at 52% each, and health, fitness, and wellness at 46%. Experiences or event tickets (40%), gift cards (38%), and travel (35%) ranked lowest.
Women were the most likely to say they would buy beauty and personal care products this season based on a creator’s recommendation.
Gender was the most consistent divide across the survey, according to the report, with women ahead on saving, buying, and planning creator-recommended gifts.
Respondents ranged in age from 18 to 84, with an average age of 45.5. The Center for the Creator Economy launched in 2025 as a joint initiative of Syracuse University’s S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications and Martin J. Whitman School of Management, and publishes monthly Flash Reports.
Image source: Syracuse University The full report is availablehere
Dragomir is a Serbian freelance blog writer and translator. He is passionate about covering insightful stories and exploring topics such as influencer marketing, the creator economy, technology, business, and cyber fraud.
Half of U.S. adults made at least one purchase on a creator’s recommendation during the 2025 holiday shopping season, and 85% of those buyers say they are likely to do it again this year, according to a new survey from Syracuse University’s Center for the Creator Economy.
The center’s second “Flash Report,” dated November 2026, surveyed 988 U.S. adults through Prolific on November 7 and 8. The sample is nationally representative by gender, age, ethnicity, and political affiliation. Respondents answered questions about last year’s holiday shopping, defined as September through December 2025, and about their plans for this season.
Across all respondents, 61% said they are somewhat or very likely to buy a creator-recommended gift this season. Among adults who did not buy on a creator’s recommendation last year, or were unsure whether they had, the share falls to 22%.
Creator Influence Peaked on the Biggest Shopping Days
Creator recommendations reached shoppers on the season’s highest-traffic days. Of all respondents, 37% bought on a creator’s recommendation on Black Friday, 26% did so on Cyber Monday, and 33% bought a creator-recommended item as a last-minute gift.
Women were more likely than men to have made a creator-recommended purchase last season, and more likely to plan one this season, the report found.
Three in Four Save Gift Ideas From Creators
Seventy-seven percent of U.S. adults save gift ideas from creators, and most do so with other people in mind. Sixty-five percent save creator posts as gift ideas for others, including 47% who save for both themselves and others. Another 10.6% save ideas only to buy for themselves later, while 22.6% do not save creator gift ideas at all.
Women and adults ages 18 to 44 were the most likely to save gift ideas from creators.
Among the 765 respondents who saved gift ideas, Instagram (60%), YouTube (59%), and TikTok (53%) were the leading platforms where those ideas are stored. Facebook followed at 43.5% and Pinterest at 20.3%. The order shifts when respondents pass ideas along. Among the 529 who had shared or planned to share saved products with family or friends as a wish list, Instagram ranked first at 59%, followed by TikTok at 54% and YouTube at 48%.
Shoppers See Deal Posts as Ads, and Many Still Use Them
Seventy percent of respondents agree that creators’ Black Friday and Cyber Monday deal promotions are “mostly just advertising,” with 35% agreeing strongly. At the same time, 53% agree that creators help them find deals that are “actually worth it.”
Most adults also say they can identify paid content. Fifty-six percent are “very” or “extremely” confident they could tell when a creator is being paid to promote a product, and 59% say the same about spotting a commission link. Confidence drops to 45% when a creator is promoting a product received for free from the brand.
Creators Trail Brands Narrowly on Trust
Friends and family remain the most trusted source of gift ideas, with 75% of adults trusting them “very much” or “completely.” Customer reviews followed at 48% on the same measure.
On a broader measure of moderate or higher trust, creators reached 53%, compared with 55% for brands, 47% for AI, and 25% for celebrities. Twenty-four percent of respondents said they do not trust AI at all for gift ideas, and 39% said the same of celebrities.
Creators also steer some shoppers away from purchases. Sixteen percent of respondents, or 158 people, said a creator talked them out of a gift last season. Among that group, 38% were pointed to a better or higher-quality alternative, 25% to a cheaper alternative, and 23% were talked out of the product altogether. Smaller shares cited a more sustainable alternative (8.2%), a suggestion to craft the gift instead (3.8%), or encouragement to give experiences over gifts (1.9%).
Beauty and Fashion Lead Creator-Influenced Categories
Beauty and personal care topped the list of creator-influenced gift categories at 68%, followed by clothing, shoes, and accessories at 66%, electronics and gadgets at 64%, and home and kitchen at 61%. Toys and games came in at 56%, food and drink and books at 52% each, and health, fitness, and wellness at 46%. Experiences or event tickets (40%), gift cards (38%), and travel (35%) ranked lowest.
Women were the most likely to say they would buy beauty and personal care products this season based on a creator’s recommendation.
Gender was the most consistent divide across the survey, according to the report, with women ahead on saving, buying, and planning creator-recommended gifts.
Respondents ranged in age from 18 to 84, with an average age of 45.5. The Center for the Creator Economy launched in 2025 as a joint initiative of Syracuse University’s S.I. Newhouse School of Public Communications and Martin J. Whitman School of Management, and publishes monthly Flash Reports.
Image source: Syracuse University
The full report is available here
Subscribe to Our Newsletter
Check Out Our Podcast